Alright, alright, alright.
I finally took some serious time to listen to Mumford & Sons. Was at a friend's house and everyone was busy with something else and I wanted to sit and rest, so I put in the older CD and plugged in the headphones he got on my recommendation and I listened. First I just tried a casual relaxed approach to see if the feel and emotions were appealing. Then I tried the deeper analysis of the instruments and musicianship. Finally I studied the recording itself for style, character, and editing prowress.
After three passes of the CD, I have come to the conclusion that I don't really find this band appealing at all. The songwriting uses all the same tired gimmicks hoisted on us in the post Emo whiner era (think mad at Dad alternative baritone rock). The arrangements are not that appealing. And the performances are average, at best. While the combination of Irish acoustical instruments and Canadian misery rock is interesting and kinda different, it really doesn't rise above either for me. I'd rather listen to the Chieftons and Pearl Jam separately.
But that's just me. I also never figured out how anyone could like Radiohead or anything U2 did after 1989.
You guys enjoy!